About

Addressing persistent problems requires a different approach to problem solving.

Many technical, environmental, and social problems are difficult to solve, yet modest in scope. They thus require an ATOMISTIC approach to problem solving — i.e., a deep dive into a narrow area. On the other hand, many of the world’s persistent problems are intertwined within society's technical, socioeconomic, and environmental systems and thus require a HOLISTIC or SYSTEMS approach to managing trade-offs.

Atomism

Isolate the piece, then drill down.

To make the deep dive, the problem solver separates one part of the system from the rest and works inside that boundary. That atomistic approach has produced many advances in technology and human welfare. It is the right tool when the problem really is narrow.

Holism

See the field, then see how the pieces interact.

Persistent problems ask for the opposite. The scope has to be holistic, the work interdisciplinary, and the effort a team’s. Systems thinking is the ability to hold the big picture and still track how the parts act on one another.

“If we were to release a modern astronaut into ancient Greece, he would be able to understand their problems, their social institutions, their ethical dilemmas — for they are essentially the same as our own. But he could not communicate with them technologically; a computer or a jet airplane would be incomprehensible.”

B. F. Skinner

Tame versus Persistent Problems

Rittel and Webber distinguish tame, or benign, problems from persistent ones. Tame problems are relatively straightforward and yield to traditional methods. Persistent problems are complex, ambiguous, and resistant to typical problem-solving techniques. They are characterized by their nonlinear nature, open-endedness, and the interconnectedness of their variables. As such they are “addressed” rather than “solved” because changing a system's structure almost always means managing trade-offs, not finding a clean solution.

Leaders are systems thinkers

Addressing society’s persistent problems requires leadership. Leaders act. They see the big picture. They manage teams. They are generalists, not specialists.

Three worlds, blended

The work blends knowledge from the technical world, the natural world, and the social world. None of the three is enough on its own.

How decision makers learn it

System dynamics modeling and gaming. Build a computer model. Turn it into a serious game — a flight simulator, an interactive learning environment. Test it with human subjects. Put it on a server and invite people to train in it, and learn to fly the system.

A feedback account of why these problems persist

Negative feedback

Policy resistance

The system pushes back. A policy that looks correct in isolation is offset by the rest of the structure. One source of that conflict is the gap between ceremonial and instrumental ways of acting.

Positive feedback

Path dependence and inferior lock-in

Success reinforces itself. An early path, even a poorer one, can lock in and become harder to leave the longer it runs.

What to do

Look for the feedback structure and change it at leverage points. Be ready for better-before-worse, and for worse-before-better. A redesign that improves the system in the long run can look like a failure in the short run, and the reverse is just as common.